Legal Services Commissioner’s ‘Moral Compass’ is Kaput!

In her article, “Government lawyers the ‘moral compass’ of their organisations” which I have reproduced in full below, Karin Derkley sets out the message that IBAC Commissioner Robert Redlich delivered the LIV Government Lawyers conference last year.

The Victorian Legal Services Commissioner, Ms Fiona McLeay, seems to understand that ethics must be lived and cannot just be reduced to mere rules. And apparently she is also aware that being fit and proper involves holding oneself to a higher ethical standard of behaviour than the general public.

However, when it comes to common behaviours that characterise misconduct and corruption, such as a culture of denial, obfuscation and concealment, and a failure of those in positions of management and supervision to be as forthcoming as they should be about misconduct, Ms McLeay seems unable to reconcile her own conduct with her supposed ideals.

Considering the conduct of Ms McLeay and various officers under her supervision in light of the observations of IBAC Commissioner Robert Redlich, my conclusion is that Ms McLeay’s moral compass is well and truly broken.

I have gone to considerable effort to inform, assist and guide Ms McLeay but she seems determined to rely on her own malfunctioning moral compass and her survival instincts. These survival instincts include an apparent need to deny everything, admit nothing and to cover up that which might incriminate. Or, as Commissioner Robert Redlich describes it, “…an organisational culture of denial, obfuscation and concealment, and a failure of those in positions of management and supervision to be as forthcoming as they should be about misconduct“.

Ms McLeay’s conduct has been such that I have had no alternative but to conduct my own investigation into the cultural corruption that now pervades her office, and to do so publicly.

Over coming weeks and months I will fill these pages with evidence of corrupt and criminal conduct in the hope that, eventually, someone with authority and a working moral compass will step in and take over from me.

For the time being I invite visitors to read through Commissioner Redlich’s address to the LIV Government Lawyers conference, set out below, and to bear his observations in mind while reading through the material presented in the pages of this website:

“IBAC Commissioner Robert Redlich told the LIV Government Lawyers conference that government lawyers have a greater responsibility than lawyers “who hang their shingle on the street“.

You are lawyers to these organisations… You have to make sure that your organisation is always aligned to true north and that its moral compass is right.

While IBAC investigates only a small proportion of complaints about government agencies and instrumentalities, including Victoria Police, it conducts reviews of matters that have been investigated by other bodies.

Through those reviews, as well as investigations and research, it has been able to identify common behaviours that characterise misconduct and corruption, Mr Redlich said.

They included an organisational culture of denial, obfuscation and concealment, and a failure of those in positions of management and supervision “to be as forthcoming as they should be about misconduct“.

Managers are too often complicit in whatever sort of coverage or hiding of what occurred,” he said. “They don’t express a willingness to publicly expose what has occurred within their organisation.

That had particularly been the case in “hierarchical para-military organisations” such as Victoria Police, which can lead to misguided loyalty. “That ‘I’ve got your back’ culture comes from a para-military concept, but that shouldn’t mean I will protect you if you do the wrong thing.

Combined with unrealistic KPIs, that culture had led, for instance, to the widespread practice of police falsifying breath tests in order to meet a ramped up breath testing target. “Many police rationalised the misconduct because of the unrealistic and impossible KPI which caused people to cut corners,” he said.

Corruption is not just serious crime or misconduct, Mr Redlich pointed out. “It starts with a failure to adhere to processes, an arrangement that involves conflict of interest, nepotism, and looking the other way in relation to a failure to strictly adhere to the requirements of the organisation.

None of us are immune from risks of corruption,” he said. “(There have been) failures at an extraordinary level by leadership that failed to insist on compliance with elementary processes.

Government lawyers needed to ensure they gave “honest fearless advice“, and to recognise that they played a role in building a culture that was ethical and followed proper procedures.

They also needed to support those who are in a position to speak out “and make sure they get the full protection of the law in relation to being courageous“, Mr Redlich said.”


No Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Please confirm that you are a human and not a spam bot *